Luggage guide
The bag weighs something too
Cabin luggage is sold on looks and bought on hope. Two numbers decide whether it works, both are published, and almost nobody compares them before paying.
Your allowance includes the suitcase
This is the arithmetic that should come first and almost never does. Tumi's aluminium cabin case is 5.3kg empty and holds 35 litres. Samsonite's Proxis cabin is 2.2kg and holds 38 litres. That is three kilos heavier for three litres less, from bags that sit in the same part of the market.
Put it against a real limit and it stops being abstract. Briggs & Riley publish the airline tables their bags are measured against, and Virgin Atlantic's cabin allowance there is 12kg. The Tumi uses nearly half of that before anything goes in it; the Samsonite uses under a fifth. On any airline weighing cabin bags, the empty weight is the specification that decides what you can take.
- Tumi state the dimensions, weight, capacity and material together. Tumi
- Samsonite state the same four things for their cabin case. Samsonite
- Briggs & Riley publish the airline limits their bags are measured against. Briggs & Riley
Aluminium is a decision about how it looks
Aluminium cases are beautiful, they dent rather than crack, and they are the heaviest thing in the category by a wide margin. That is the whole trade and it is a legitimate one: a dented aluminium case looks like a well-travelled object, where a scuffed polycarbonate one just looks tired.
What it is not is a durability argument that justifies itself. Modern polypropylene and polycarbonate shells flex and return; aluminium takes the mark permanently. If you want the patina, buy it knowingly and accept the kilos. If what you actually wanted was a bag that survives baggage handlers, the lighter shell is not the compromise.
The dimensions belong to the airline, not the maker
Cabin size is not a standard, and the honest makers say so. Bric's answer the question about their 55 x 37 x 23cm case with "meet most airline cabin baggage allowances", which is exactly right and is a qualifier worth noticing. Depth is where bags fail: 23cm clears some carriers and not others, and it is the dimension the sizer catches.
Measure against the tightest airline you genuinely use rather than the most generous, because the penalty is paid at the gate at the worst moment and at the highest price. A bag that is 2cm too deep is a bag you will eventually check.
- Bric's answer the cabin question with a qualifier rather than a yes. Case Luggage
- Briggs & Riley publish the airline limits their bags are measured against. Briggs & Riley
And the warranty, which here actually ranges
Luggage is one of the few categories where the guarantee genuinely separates the field rather than clustering. Tumi give five years, Samsonite ten, Carl Friedrik a lifetime warranty. Over the life of a case that is a real difference, because what fails is wheels and handles rather than the shell, and those are repairs rather than write-offs.
The question to ask is what the guarantee covers rather than how long it runs. Airline damage is the most likely thing to happen to a suitcase and the thing most often excluded, so a shorter warranty that covers handling can be worth more than a lifetime one that does not.
- Tumi give five years. Tumi
- Samsonite give ten. Samsonite
- Carl Friedrik give a lifetime warranty. Carl Friedrik
Researched 2026-11-08. Prices are what the retailer asked on that date.